|
Popular culture goes to the dogs By Joseph Popiolkowski, USA TODAY
The cultural landscape in America is nothing if
not a tableau for fads and trends that drive certain objects in and out
of style.
Clothing? Consider how bell-bottom jeans of the
1970s gave way to tight-fitting bleached jeans in the 1980s, pleated
khakis in the 1990s and the flat-front low-rise capris of today.
A Western Carolina University psychology
professor now has the proof that the same cultural winds direct
people's choice in dogs.
"At some point dogs went from being a custom —
something that people kept because they were important in their lives
and had utility — to a fashion," says Hal Herzog, who has studied
animal-human interaction nearly 20 years.
 | | The
10 most popular purebred dogs in 2003, according to registrations
recorded with the American Kennel Club. | Breed | 2002 | 2003 | | Labrador retriever | 154,616 | 144,934 | | Golden retriever | 56,124 | 52,530 | | Beagle | 44,610 | 45,033 | | German shepherd | 46,963 | 43,950 | | Dachshund | 42,571 | 39,473 | | Yorkshire terrier | 37,277 | 38,256 | | Boxer | 34,340 | 34,136 | | Poodle | 33,917 | 32,176 | | Shih Tzu | 28,294 | 26,935 | Source: American Kennel Club | | |  |
Herzog and two colleagues studied the American
Kennel Club's purebred registration records for the past 57 years —
leaving him with a sample size of 48 million — and concluded that dog
breeds go in and out of style the same way clothing, music and food
styles do. This year, for example, the hottest breeds are the Havanese,
Cavalier King Charles spaniels, Brussels griffons and French bulldogs —
all small, cute dogs that adjust well to city life and apartment living.
The old standards of Labrador and golden
retrievers, German shepherds and beagles always will be popular, but
exotic breeds will make inroads from time to time, says Jim Crowley,
executive secretary of the AKC.
Most often, a breed boom is a result of
word-of-mouth or the influence of a personal network, but sometimes it
comes from a popular movie, Herzog says.
For example, the number of English sheepdogs
registered with the AKC rose from 149 in 1960 to more than 16,000 in
1974 after Disney's The Shaggy Dog came out in 1959, Herzog says. For most breeds though, it doesn't take a movie.
The poodle rose from 6,000 to 250,000
registrations during the 1950s with no movie to explain the shift. The
poodle's popularity rubbed off: Remember the poodle skirt?
"At some point in dog evolution, a human's
cultural preferences in the form of fashion became a major driving
force in breed popularity," Herzog says.
The Dalmatian rose to fame in the 1990s with the release of Disney's 101Dalmatians, Herzog says.
Buyers, however, weren't careful enough in considering whether that breed was suitable for them.
"They're very nice dogs, but they're not for everybody," he says.
The result was the wrong kind of boom: Lots of Dalmatians ended up at animal shelters.
And bad breed choices are becoming all too common, Herzog says.
Choosing a dog "is a lifestyle choice," Crowley
says. Buyers need to consider how active they are and whether they live
in an urban or rural setting and make decisions based on those factors,
not what's dominating popular culture.
"You need to choose a dog you can live with and one that can live with you," Crowley says.
When the Brussels griffon was featured in the movie As Good As It Gets,
breeders anticipated a rise in registrations and cautioned buyers that
it might not be the dog for them. Brussels griffons tend to be shy, are
not compatible with children and can be difficult to house-train.
"Breeders are aware that this is a problem, and responsible ones are trying to do something about it," Herzog says.
Herzog also cited the Rottweiller's climb from
25th to second most popular breed from 1976 to 1993 and its subsequent
fall after a spate of fatal attacks.
"Right now they're in the middle of a big crash," he says.
Insurance companies have put exclusions on
homeowner policies on certain breeds that are prone to more aggressive
behavior, such as the Rottweiller, which contributes to its "negative
stereotype," Crowley says.
Herzog says his mathematical model will be useful for analyzing other social changes, such as baby names.
Breeds and names ride a wave of popularity for several years before an ultimate burst — a natural consequence of the boom.
"While this study is superficially about dog
breed changes, and it's pretty cool in that regard, it's also an
incredibly nice model for looking at rapid changes in culture."
|